On April 10 2017, the Fundamental Science Review was published — a review of Canada’s fundamental science and research ecosystem, including 35 recommendations. As the review approaches its eight-year anniversary, Evidence for Democracy carried out a third review of the recommendations.
On June 13, 2016, then Minister of Science, the Honorable Kirsty Duncan, launched the Advisory Panel on Federal Support for Fundamental Science. Led by Dr. David Naylor, former President of the University of Toronto, the panel was asked to “take stock of the steps required to preserve Canada’s world-class standing” through a review of Canada’s fundamental science and research ecosystem.
The resulting Fundamental Science Review (FSR, sometimes referred to as the Naylor Report), was released on April 10, 2017, outlining 35 recommendations to strengthen the foundations of Canadian extramural research (i.e. science being led by researchers working in universities, hospitals and other research institutes).
In the years since its release, the FSR has become a rallying cry for the Canadian science community, directly influencing further calls for research support. But overall progress has been uneven — in 2019, E4D carried out an initial review of the FSR recommendations, and remarked that we are still a long way from the finish line.
Now, as we near the eight-year anniversary of the review, we wondered: how far have we come with the FSR since our last look in 2021?
Today, we are pleased to share our third review of the status of the FSR recommendations. Overall, we found that of the 35 FSR recommendations, 11 are complete, 14 are in progress, and 10 remain unresolved.

Our analysis of progress on the Fundamental Science Review took a step-by-step approach, by looking at what has been addressed and what remains to be done for each recommendation. The status of each recommendation was sorted into three categories: complete, in progress, and unresolved.
Completed
Since 2021, the federal government has completed one additional core recommendation. It has successfully consolidated existing digital research infrastructure into two leadership organizations (CANARIE and the Digital Research Alliance of Canada), and provided these organizations with new funding and a strong national mandate (#6.9).
In Progress
The federal government has also acted to initiate significant progress on several recommendations regarding research governance. Since our last 2021 update, the Science, Technology and Innovation Council has been wound down (#4.2), the government has initiated its search for members for the upcoming Council on Science and Innovation (#4.3), and has clarified its intention to integrate key federal departments into the council (#4.4, #4.6).
Incomplete
Unfortunately, nearly a third of all recommendations remain incomplete as of January 2025. Additionally, we determined that one recommendation has regressed significantly since our last 2021 review – the FSR recommendation to create a Tri-Council joint mechanism to allocated funds for fast-breaking issues (#6.7). During the pandemic, the federal government announced temporary rapid review mechanisms to allocate funds for fast-breaking public health issues. However, since the official end of the pandemic, these efforts have largely faltered. No joint mechanism has been permanently installed, and no mention has been made in recent announcements, including Budget 2024 and Fall Economic Statement 2024.
As you can imagine, tracking every one of the FSR recommendations is challenging! Have we missed a key detail? Please get in touch with us (at info@evidencefordemocracy.ca).
Authors:
Trevor Potts is the Director of Research and Policy at Evidence for Democracy.
Evidence for Democracy would like to especially thank Amna Malik, Brandon Sawh, John Gilbert, Jon Coutinho, Katrina Hiiback, Lucy Shen, and Max Genin for providing their insights and expertise during the analysis of the Fundamental Science Review recommendations. This work would not have been possible without their support.
