On 28 January 2025, Commissioner Marie-Josee Hogue held a press conference on the Foreign Interference Commission’s final report, where she identified misinformation as the single greatest existential threat to Canadian democracy. Our research team at Evidence for Democracy carried out a broad review of the state of misinformation in Canada, and what we can do to rebuild public trust in Canada’s democracy.
It’s been less than a year since Commissioner Hogue released her groundbreaking report, showing definitively that misinformation poses the single largest threat to Canadian democracy. These harms manifest in very real ways that affect Canadians, including generating malicious sexual deepfakes, sowing public distrust in climate scientists and public health experts, and amplifying hate speech against minority communities.
Evidence for Democracy recognized these threats early on during the pandemic, releasing our seminal Misinformation in Canada report. But much has changed since that time, particularly with the rise of artificial intelligence.
Canada’s unique challenges and vulnerabilities are driven by an increasingly digitalized media landscape dominated by foreign content, a significant decline in public trust for traditional news sources, and the growing influence of very large online platforms (VLOPs) such as Meta and TikTok. New technological changes in social media and artificial intelligence, as well as unregulated online spaces, make it far too easy for misusers to rapidly create and spread misinformation, which ultimately amplifies polarization between Canadian communities and erodes our democratic institutions. The misinformation-driven trucker occupation of Ottawa is the perfect example where misinformation radically altered behaviours and beliefs, and directly led to very real harms for Ottawa residents and businesses, including physical violence, sexual harassment, hate speech, and over $37 million in damages to the city.
While technological innovations have moved quickly, the Canadian government’s legislative and policy responses have been slow-paced and cautious. Most Canadian laws instead target the harms of misinformation in limited circumstances (e.g. hate speech, defamation, and fraud), while attempts to broadly criminalize both misinformation and disinformation (e.g. Online Harms Act, 2024) have faced repeated constitutional challenges, rarely passing into law. Newer proposals have since focused on high-risk areas (e.g. election interference) but have failed to pass through Parliament due to persistent political opposition and legal hurdles.
Our in-depth report demonstrates that misinformation has significant impacts on Canadians’ personal beliefs, civic behaviours, and public trust. Marginalized communities, including Indigenous and gender-diverse groups, have been seriously harmed by disinformation-fuelled activities, which has disrupted their access to social services, and, in many cases, manifested as physical violence and psychological harm. These disinformation campaigns are frequently driven by foreign actors using advanced AI technologies and manipulation techniques (eg deepfakes), exploiting online platforms to target communities and disrupt elections. Simultaneously, low levels of digital media literacy and fallen public trust in traditional news outlets have left Canadians even more vulnerable to misinformation-driven manipulation.
Ultimately, efforts to counter misinformation in Canada must be multi-faceted. This means we need targeted government regulation, consistent content moderation and algorithmic transparency on social media platforms, and sustained investment in digital media literacy for Canadians. Furthermore, international best practices, especially the EU Digital Services Act and EU Artificial Intelligence Act, provide models for improved platform accountability, content regulation, and risk management – models which we can use to build our own legislation and strategies. Our report outlines a variety of policy options, including clearer legislation on AI-generated content, a new centralized federal monitoring entity, systemic safeguards for vulnerable groups, and a renewed commitment to public trust and democratic resilience in the digital age.
Canada’s democracy is under threat from misinformation, which is actively undermining evidence and experts, sowing distrust in our institutions, and harming our most vulnerable communities. It is essential that we take action to safeguard our democracy and ensure that evidence-informed decision-making continues to build a better future for all Canadians.
